Blog & News

Patterns of Play: A View From the Premier League

Written by Mindflick | Nov 20, 2025 2:47:48 PM

After James Kerr helped us unpack the deep cultural foundations behind high performance in Part 1 — identity, belonging, behavioural clarity, and peer-driven standards — Part 2 moves from who we are to how we perform when the environment shifts.

This webinar with Dr Ian Mitchell (Newcastle United), Dr Mike Rotheram, and Dr Philippa McGregor explored the applied side of Patterns of Play: how elite teams execute, adapt, and stay aligned when things get messy.

One theme ran through every story: High-performing teams don’t wait for stability. They perform through instability.

Here’s how they do it.

1. Build Trust Daily - Not When You Need It

Part 1 showed that strong cultures create belonging. Part 2 reveals the natural next step: belonging fuels trust, and trust fuels performance under pressure.

Elite teams intentionally build two forms of trust:

  • Task Trust I can rely on your work.

  • Relationship Trust I can rely on your intentions.

Our Patterns of Play research reinforces this. Teams that combine both forms of trust show higher resilience, faster decision-making, and stronger alignment during change . Trust behaves like a currency:

  • Earned through delivery and connection beyond role/task.

  • Protected through clarity, early check in's and proactive communication.

  • Spent through challenge, honesty, and making tough decisions that matter.

Teams that build trust proactively waste less energy navigating doubt — and more energy performing.

2. Perform Through Change, Not After It.

In Part 1, identity became the anchor. In Part 2, adaptability becomes the movement around that anchor.

Most teams want to wait for things to settle before working on performance. Elite teams do the opposite:

  • They practise scenario-based decision-making

  • They use principles, not rigid rules

  • They constantly ask, “What does the situation require?”

  • They normalise new rhythms rather than cling to old ones

Our Patterns of Play data backs this up: nearly 70% of high-performing teams report that change is a permanent condition, not a temporary disruption — and their performance systems reflect that.

Adaptability becomes an advantage when change is constant — not an interruption.

3. Make Challenge Safe, Expected, and Useful

Part 1 introduced challenge as a cultural norm. Part 2 shows how teams apply it under pressure.

Challenge is not conflict. Its contribution.

But for challenge to work, it must be 1) invited, 2) protect and 3) normalised. 

High-performing teams understand that challenge: sharpens thinking, reduces blind spots, accelerates alignment and strengthens decisions in uncertain conditions. 

This aligns with our report findings: teams with strong behavioural norms — the conditions that make challenge safe — show 30% higher performance and 71% higher satisfaction.

4. Build Resilience Into the Environment - Not the Individual

Resilience isn’t a heroic trait. It’s a system. Teams sustain performance when leaders create environments where people can:

  • Pause and reflect

  • Reinforce identity under stress

  • Access meaningful recovery habits

  • Reset quickly rather than spiral

  • Navigate pressure with support, not isolation

As Ian Mitchell shared, high-stakes teams must “resource the environment” — so people have something to lean on when it matters. Resilience becomes collective, not individual.

5. Spot the Drift Before It Spreads

Part 1 introduced drift. Part 2 offers the response. Drift begins quietly:

  • A moment of lateness

  • A softened standard

  • A missed conversation

  • A behaviour unchallenged

The teams that win through change:

  • Notice micro-behaviours early

  • Use peer groups to self-correct

  • Treat drift as data, not drama

  • Refuse to outsource standards to hierarchy

This isn’t policing behaviour. It’s protecting the identity built in Part 1.

Putting It Together: From Foundations to Performance

When Part 1 and Part 2 come together, a simple pattern emerges:

Teams win because they know who they are. Teams keep winning because they know how to adapt.

Part 1: identity, belonging, behavioural clarity, and peer ownership.

Part 2: trust, adaptability, challenge, resilience, and change-readiness.

Together, they form a complete blueprint for teams navigating speed, pressure, and constant change. Part 3 in the series explores how teams turn these insights into daily habit and rhythm — the systems that turn culture into action and pressure into performance.